Erin Weiser

Indonesia’s haze impacts significantly wealthier neighbours. Why aren’t they doing more about it?

Singapore and Malaysia suffer from Indonesia’s recurring haze, yet their banks and businesses help finance the deforestation and fires behind it. Erin Weiser argues that protecting their citizens and economies means confronting those financial ties and using their leverage to keep forests standing and stop the burning.

On a recent trip to Jakarta, I walked out of the airport into a sulphur sky and drove into town where skyscrapers were visible only as impressionistic outlines through air that looked as if it was solid. Poor air quality in Jakarta is par for the course, but you know things are bad when people living on the street are spending their desperately few rupiah to buy masks.

Indonesia is suffering through its worst fire season since 2015 and is likely to exceed that milestone. Exacerbated by this year’s El Nino, independent sources report that 1.9 million hectares had burned through September, 38% higher than the same period in 2019, and on track to meet the 2.6 million hectares burned in 2015.

These now regularly occurring events are so significant that they push Indonesia into the rank of top global emitters of greenhouse gases. Indonesia is second only to Brazil in contributing to global deforestation (10 million hectares between 2015 - 2024, compared to 23 million hectares in Brazil), and, after dropping dramatically after 2016, are again on the rise. The vast majority of deforestation is occurring legally; independent estimates are that 74% of current hotspots in the province of Kalimantan are inside corporate concession areas.

“The Haze” resulting from this deforestation has become almost anthropomorphic – a force of nature wreaking its vengeance on the powerless citizens of Southeast Asia. But unlike the Brazil case, where neighbouring countries are of equivalent or lower economic clout, the neighbouring countries breathing in Indonesia’s haze are wealthier than the source country by orders of magnitude. Singapore (GDP per capita 20 times Indonesia’s), Brunei (8 times higher), and Malaysia (three times higher) are regularly suffering economic damages calculated in the billions of euros along with health and education impacts (2 million students affected by school closures in Malaysia alone).

Wealthier neighbours, conflicting interests

In principle, wealthier neighbours have both the economic motivation and the institutional capacity to pressure the source country to prevent burning. Unfortunately, the wealth that should make Indonesia’s neighbours more able to push back has instead made them complicit in the status quo. It is time for a new approach if they are serious about protecting their populations and their economies.

The limits of diplomacy and legal action

To date, Singapore and Malaysia (with Brunei as junior diplomatic partner) have pursued legal and diplomatic channels to influence Indonesia’s forest management and fire mitigation policies. Malaysia was a key proponent behind the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (AATHP), the first ASEAN Member State to ratify (in 2002), and a consistent source of diplomatic pressure on Indonesia before the latter finally ratified in 2014. The AATHP is criticised as toothless due to its lack of an enforcement mechanism, although it creates a framework for cooperation.

More consequentially, Singapore passed the Transboundary Haze Act in 2014, extending extraterritorial criminal and civil liability for companies responsible for haze affecting Singapore. So far in 2026, ten Indonesian companies have been served notices to stop burning on their land under the law. The inefficacy of the law is demonstrated by the fact that three of these ten are repeat offenders from 2015. No company has ever been fined under the law.

If these efforts have had limited effect, it would seem to be time to try financial incentives. And here, the Singaporean and Malaysian governments have a lot of leverage if they are willing to use it.

Malaysia’s leverage over plantation companies

Malaysian palm oil firms – as they have nowhere left to legally deforest at home – are now the largest foreign investors in Indonesian concessions. Malaysian-linked capital was behind 30,000 hectares of Indonesian rainforest clearing in 2023 alone. Malaysia could enact and enforce its own version of Singapore’s Transboundary Haze Act and work with KL-headquartered companies to incentivize them to use the same more sustainable techniques (intensification, water-table requirements for peatlands) that they now apply in Malaysia.

Singapore’s leverage over finance and trade

Meanwhile, Singapore hosts the headquarters of the world’s largest palm oil trader and is an important financial hub for concession holders. Singapore's three main banks provided loans of SGD 5.8 billion (approximately Euro 4 billion at current exchange rates) to 15 major palm oil companies as of 2017. While Singaporean prosecutors are using satellite images and forensic accounting to identify and prosecute responsible companies, highlighting the challenges to establishing legal liability, cutting off access to capital and financial markets for irresponsible plantation investors would be a much faster fix.

As noted by regional commentators, Singapore could leverage its power as a commodity trading hub by requiring companies listed on the SGX or seeking to borrow in Singapore to prove they engage in mandatory due diligence and supply chain transparency. This would immediately impact the big Indonesian players that have been shielded until now by the Indonesian government. Indonesia wouldn’t be able to play the sovereignty card and Singapore, in the worst-case scenario that some business went elsewhere, could certainly absorb the loss as the price for increased pressure on firms that are directly damaging its interests.

Bringing China into the conversation

Finally, given the strategic importance of the issue for Singapore, it may wish to deploy some diplomatic capital on the demand side of the problem as well by raising the issue of palm oil sustainability with China. While China has shown little appetite to date for mandating sustainable practices by its palm oil players, the current geopolitical context creates some interesting incentives. Setting mandatory sustainability requirements would allow China to burnish its credentials as a global “green” leader with Europe during a time of tense trade negotiations and provide tangible proof of its goodwill towards ASEAN at a time when the U.S. is pulling back from its partnerships there.

While Singapore and Malaysia are suffering from the haze, they are simultaneously financing it, undermining their own pressure on Indonesia. Asking a poorer neighbour to impose moratoriums and no-burn regulations, while being unable to confront the financial players profiting in your own capital markets, is a difficult case to make. It is certainly not a strategy that is working.

About the author

Erin Weiser has over 25 years of experience in international development, specializing in gender and trade, SME policy, and citizen engagement. She has provided advisory services to international organizations including ADB, UNDP, USAID, the World Bank, ASEAN, and APEC. Previously, she served as Director of Economic Programs at The Asia Foundation in Indonesia.

Collaborations  



Building a sustainable future through collaborative research and actionable insights for a better tomorrow.

info@futurehorizonsinstitute.org

©2026 Future Horizons Institute Org nr. 934 158 652

Collaborations  



Building a sustainable future through collaborative research and actionable insights for a better tomorrow.

info@futurehorizonsinstitute.org

©2026 Future Horizons Institute Org nr. 934 158 652

Collaborations  



Building a sustainable future through collaborative research and actionable insights for a better tomorrow.

info@futurehorizonsinstitute.org

©2026 Future Horizons Institute Org nr. 934 158 652